Skip to content
The Upside
Link copied to clipboard

She was shamed for still having her Christmas lights up. So neighbors have theirs back up in solidarity.

“We heard about the letter, and that night we turned our lights back on,” said Elaine Murray, 42, who lives around the corner from Pascucci. “No one is going to tell us to turn them off.”

The Pascucci family of Long Island received an anonymous letter scolding them for still having Christmas lights up. Sara Pascucci said her family was not ready to remove the decorations after losing both her father and aunt to covid-19 in January. MUST CREDIT: Sara Pascucci
The Pascucci family of Long Island received an anonymous letter scolding them for still having Christmas lights up. Sara Pascucci said her family was not ready to remove the decorations after losing both her father and aunt to covid-19 in January. MUST CREDIT: Sara PascucciRead more

A neighborhood on Long Island is covered in Christmas decorations — and not because people neglected to take them down.

Although the holiday season is long past, twinkly lights and festive ornaments recently reappeared on the streets of Bethpage, in a show of support for a grieving neighbor.

It started when Sara Pascucci received a letter in the mail on Feb. 3 scolding her for still having Christmas decorations up.

The anonymous, typed letter read: “Take your Christmas lights down! Its Valentines Day!!!!!!”

While the letter would have upset her in normal circumstances, Pascucci said, it hit especially hard now. She lost both her father and her aunt to COVID-19 in January, less than one week apart.

Her father, who lived with her, put up the Christmas decorations immediately after Thanksgiving — as he did every year. In the weeks following his death on Jan. 15, Pascucci couldn’t bring herself to take the decorations down. Receiving the harsh letter, she said, was “a major blow to the heart.”

“No one really knows what is going on inside the house or why we didn’t take down the decorations,” said Pascucci, 31. “I couldn’t believe someone would do this.”

She shared the letter in the Long Island Moms Facebook group and explained why it was particularly painful, in the hopes that the anonymous sender might see her post.

“For anyone in the Bethpage area — if you know of a person who would do something so insensitive like this please pass along my message,” Pascucci wrote.

Over the past several weeks, the family has been preoccupied with “funeral arrangements, mortgage/utility payments, and just the grieving process of it all,” Pascucci explained in the post. “So yes, we haven’t gotten around to taking down his Christmas decorations. And maybe we just aren’t ready to yet. I won’t apologize for this.”

She ended the post with “Be kind to people because you never know what they are going through.”

The community was outraged on her behalf. Within minutes of her sharing the post, dozens of messages flooded Pascucci’s Facebook inbox.

Neighbors sent the Pascucci family heartfelt cards, flowers, and meals, and a GoFundMe page was created to help cover mounting mortgage payments and funeral costs.

“A man and his wife came with roses and a letter,” recalled Pascucci, who works as a receptionist for a dermatologist. “He said: ‘Keep your Christmas lights up. I know what it feels like to lose someone and not want to put their things away. It’s very hard.’”

And then many neighbors started to put their own holiday decorations up so she wouldn’t feel so alone.

“We heard about the letter, and that night we turned our lights back on,” said Elaine Murray, 42, who lives around the corner from Pascucci. “No one is going to tell us to turn them off.”

She and her family put a wreath on the front door, secured an inflatable snowman to the lawn and programmed their Christmas lights to turn on every evening at 5 in honor of Pascucci’s father, Anthony Pascucci, who was 60, and her aunt, Concetta Pascucci, who was 70 when she died Jan. 9.

“They will be missed,” said Murray, a nurse on the front lines of the pandemic. For her, the two deaths “really just hit home.”

Seeing the bright lights and decorations once again around the neighborhood gives her “something to look forward to every night,” she said.

“Especially in this time, we should all just be kind and watch what we say,” Murray added. “Sara can keep her lights on for the whole year if she wants.”

Other neighbors followed suit, and suddenly, it started to look a lot like Christmas in Bethpage. Soon, other Long Island residents stumbled upon Pascucci’s post and were inspired to get involved, too. Renee Clausen, 37, who lives nearby in West Islip, said she could relate to Pascucci’s story.

“I’ve dealt with quite a bit of loss in my family, so I know how she feels, and it’s the little things that do make you feel better and give you comfort,” said Clausen, who offered to make a small memorial on Pascucci’s front lawn for her father and aunt.

“I’ve been having a really difficult time myself,” continued Clausen, who manages a struggling restaurant. “There’s no way for me to believe there are good people in this world if I can’t be a good person myself.”

Pascucci is so awed by the kindness of her community, she said, that she’s now glad to have received that painful letter from an anonymous stranger.

“I actually want to thank that person,” she said, “for bringing me all this love and support in a time when I needed it most.”