Skip to main contentSkip to navigationSkip to key eventsSkip to navigation

Scottish independence referendum: Scotland votes no - as it happened

This article is more than 9 years old

Rolling coverage of the results of the Scottish independence referendum, with reaction and analysis as Scotland pulls back from leaving the United Kingdom

 Updated 
Fri 19 Sep 2014 02.49 EDTFirst published on Thu 18 Sep 2014 16.56 EDT
Key events
Results will update above

Live feed

Key events

Ewen MacAskill has more on Alex Salmond’s movements.

Alex Salmond and his wife Moira in private jet heading presumably for Edinburgh.

— Ewen MacAskill (@ewenmacaskill) September 19, 2014
Share
Updated at 

Gove confirms government planning 'English votes for English laws'

Here is more from Michael Gove , the Conservative chief whip, and his interview on the BBC.

It’s worth reading his quotes in full because effectively he was announcing proposals for major constitutional reform.

Earlier Gove said David Cameron would announce plans for England when he speaks later today. (See here and here.)

On the BBC, Gove provided more details.

  • Gove confirmed that the government was looking at some version of “English votes for English law”.

The Conservative party has outlined a position which I think has a lot of support, not just within Conservative circles, which is that if decisions are taken that effect only the people of England, or only the people of England, Wales and Northern, we need more clearly to respect the wishes of folk in those particular countries.

  • He suggested that this would involve draft legislation before the general election, and legislation soon after the general election - just as the government is proposing for further Scottish devolution.

Gordon Brown outlined a timetable that involves publishing a command paper that sets out some principle and some detail, then having draft clauses early in the new year, and then, by the time of a general election, a pretty clear legislative proposal that would be implemented after the United Kingdom general election for Scotland,

I think what we need to do is to have a similar sense of urgency in bringing forward proposals to ensure that at the same time as we would chose to legislate after the general election for Scotland, we would also make sure legislative change safeguarded the interests of people in England, Wales and Northern Ireland.

  • He said the government was not planning a full English parliament.

I don’t think we want to go down the route of an English parliament as has been commonly understood ... But the critical thing, I think is that there needs to be change in order to ensure that Westminster works better for the people of England and Wales and Northern Ireland.

For Cameron, one attraction of this idea is, unlike offering further devolution to Scotland, this could help the Tories. “English votes for English laws” is a proposal popular with Conservatives, and English voters, but it is one that Labour has always resisted - not least because a majority of Scottish MPs are Labour, and preventing them from voting on English-only legislation could lead to a Labour government having a UK majority, but not an English majority. AS

It’s not just the UK that’s up late tonight, writes Kayla Epstein in New York: the Scottish referendum has captured the world’s attention. A few tore their eyes from the action to say hello:

@GuardianUS watching in Hanoi, Vietnam - Craig Burgess @dialoguehealthy piping as we wait for results pic.twitter.com/NURoAtUauC

— Steve Price-Thomas (@stevept) September 19, 2014

@GuardianUS My small team and I keeping track in Pine Bluff, Arkansas! pic.twitter.com/okNG6BQMus

— Journier News (@JournierNews) September 19, 2014

@GuardianUS in New York.Watching Andrew Marr while on the sofa under my duvet--down with flu :( pic.twitter.com/ieWrlzrEKf

— dschmidle (@dschmidle) September 19, 2014

@GuardianUS @guardian a German and a Hongkonger watching results come in from portland, Maine! #indyref pic.twitter.com/c1jxczkDiW

— Sarah Mak (@smakkers) September 19, 2014

@GuardianUS @guardian Watching from Antigua & appreciating the 5 hour time difference or I'd be in my bed! pic.twitter.com/uTkHZZgJL4

— Aileen Wilson (@Aileen_Wilson) September 19, 2014

At home, can't sleep

My heart is racing, I feel jittery and I certainly can't sleep! I want to. I've got to look after 2 kids tomorrow and I know it'll be hell but I simply can't. I voted no 2 weeks ago by post. I have seen the fervour of the yes campaign and talked in hushed tones with my no friends about why we felt the UK is better together. Born in Scotland I have spent as much of my adult life in England as i have in Scotland. I have Scottish and English friends. I consider myself a socialist. I am always the first to argue for a fairer, more equal, more redistributive system. I love Scotland. But I also love Britain. I love our diversity, our achievements, our shared culture. I feel that I will lose a vital part of my ideer British. Also, as a dad of 2, I worry about the future for my kids. I know how good we have it in Scotland with devolution and the distinct systems that have grown from that. I see the risks of independence and don't like them. I see no reason to take them. Am I happy with Tory government, no. Is independence the answer, no. I want the UK to continue. I want to work with working people across the UK to oust the Tories and make a fairer UK. I am British. That is why I am worried about the break up of the UK. That is why I can't sleep.

Sent viaguardianwitness

By

Some even dressed up for the occasion.

Wearing my heart on..

Wearing my heart on..

My Flag kilt

Sent viaguardianwitness

By


There were also quite a few pets watching alongside their humans, but not all were thrilled about it.

@GuardianUS some of us are struggling to stay awake for the results pic.twitter.com/hcSNN4EU5o

— Ben Howe (@ben_howe1) September 19, 2014

In Washington, DC, one pub has decided the BBC commentary is not quite exciting enough.

The DC pub we're watching BBC coverage in has turned off the audio, and replaced it with a feed from Braveheart and, now, Trainspotting.

— Paul Lewis (@PaulLewis) September 19, 2014

Dundee - Yes 57.35%, no 42.65%

Here is the result for Dundee. It’s the first win for yes - and a good one too.

Yes: 53,620 (57.35%)

No: 39,880 (42.65%)

Turnout: 78.8%

Michael Thrasher, the elections expert, tells Sky this is better than he was expecting yes to do here on the basis of the polls.

Inverclyde - No 50.08%, yes 49.92%

Here is the Inverclyde result.

No: 27,329 (50.08%)

Yes: 27,243 (49.92%)

Turnout: 87.4%

(These got posted the wrong way round earlier. Sorry. AS)

It is not over yet, my colleague Alberto Nardelli reminds us.

Some context - just 2.3% declared in #IndyRef: yes would need just 50.2% of the remaining votes to turn it around. Still early.

— Alberto Nardelli (@AlbertoNardelli) September 19, 2014

Two thirds of our traffic for this live blog is currently coming from outside the UK. In Melbourne, Bill Gibson, owner of the House of Scotland gift shop, tells Melissa Davey he is keenly following the blog as the results roll in.

Gibson has been living in Australia since 1965 but visits his home country regularly.

He said no matter how the vote goes, it would be a win for Scotland.

“This process has been a great thing for Scotland, because the central government is now taking notice and this will change the politics over there either way,” he said.

“This vote is occurring as a culmination of the feeling that the Scottish people are not really getting a fair go.”

He’d seen that unfairness as a young man working in the shipyards of Glasgow - tough work without much reward.

“There has always been a feeling than England, and particularly people in London, were on a higher salary and didn’t have to pay for or suffer for the things we had to in Scotland,” he said.

Nevertheless, he would be hoping for a no vote.

“I’ve been thinking really deeply about this issue,” Gibson said.

“I think people need to carefully think about what effects of independence would be, and the ramifications of that, particularly economically.”

Bill Gibson, owner of the House of Scotland gift shop in Balwyn, Melbourne. Photograph: Melissa Davey/Guardian

Comments (…)

Sign in or create your Guardian account to join the discussion

Most viewed

Most viewed