How to mine Bitcoin on a 55-year-old IBM 1401 mainframe

Could an IBM mainframe from the 1960s mine Bitcoin? The idea seemed crazy, so I decided to find out. I implemented the Bitcoin hash algorithm in assembly code for the IBM 1401 and tested it on a working vintage mainframe. It turns out that this computer could mine, but so slowly it would take more than the lifetime of the universe to successfully mine a block. While modern hardware can compute billions of hashes per second, the 1401 takes 80 seconds to compute a single hash. This illustrates the improvement of computer performance in the past decades, most famously described by Moore's Law.

The photo below shows the card deck I used, along with the output of my SHA-256 hash program as printed by the line printer. (The card on the front of the deck is just for decoration; it was a huge pain to punch.) Note that the second line of output ends with a bunch of zeros; this indicates a successful hash.

How Bitcoin mining works

Bitcoin, a digital currency that can be transmitted across the Internet, has attracted a lot of attention. If you're not familiar with how it works, the Bitcoin system can be thought of as a ledger that keeps track of who owns which bitcoins, and it allows these to be transferred from one person to another. The interesting thing about Bitcoin is there's no central machine or authority keeping track of things. Instead, the records are spread across thousands of machines on the Internet.

The difficult problem with a distributed system like this is how to ensure everyone agrees on the records, so everyone agrees if a transaction is valid, even in the presence of malicious users and slow networks. The solution in Bitcoin is a process called mining—about every 10 minutes a block of outstanding transactions is mined, which makes the block official.

To prevent anyone from controlling which transactions are mined, the mining process is very difficult and competitive. In particular a key idea of Bitcoin is that mining is made very, very difficult, a technique called proof-of-work. It takes an insanely huge amount of computational effort to mine a block, but once a block has been mined, it is easy for peers on the network to verify that a block has been successfully mined. The difficulty of mining keeps anyone from maliciously taking over Bitcoin, and the ease of checking that a block has been mined lets users know which transactions are official.

As a side-effect, mining adds new bitcoins to the system. For each block mined, miners currently get 25 new bitcoins (currently worth about $6,000), which encourages miners to do the hard work of mining blocks. With the possibility of receiving $6,000 every 10 minutes, there is a lot of money in mining and people invest huge sums in mining hardware.

Mining requires a task that is very difficult to perform but easy to verify. Bitcoin mining uses cryptography, with a hash function called double SHA-256. A hash takes a chunk of data as input and shrinks it down into a smaller hash value (in this case 256 bits). With a cryptographic hash, there's no way to get a hash value you want without trying a whole lot of inputs. But once you find an input that gives the value you want, it's easy for anyone to verify the hash. Thus, cryptographic hashing becomes a good way to implement the Bitcoin "proof-of-work".

In more detail, to mine a block, you first collect the new transactions into a block. Then you hash the block to form an (effectively random) block hash value. If the hash starts with 16 zeros, the block is successfully mined and is sent into the Bitcoin network. Most of the time the hash isn't successful, so you modify the block slightly and try again, over and over billions of times. About every 10 minutes someone will successfully mine a block, and the process starts over. It's kind of like a lottery, where miners keep trying until someone "wins." It's hard to visualize just how difficult the hashing process is: finding a valid hash is less likely than finding a single grain of sand out of all the sand on Earth. To find these hashes, miners have datacenters full of specialized hardware to do this mining.

I've simplified a lot of details. For in-depth information on Bitcoin and mining, see my previous articles Bitcoins the hard way and Bitcoin mining the hard way.

The SHA-256 hash algorithm used by Bitcoin

Next, I'll discuss the hash function used in Bitcoin, which is based on a standard cryptographic hash function called SHA-256. Bitcoin uses "double SHA-256" which simply applies the SHA-256 function twice. The SHA-256 algorithm is so simple you can literally do it by hand, but it manages to scramble the data entirely unpredictably. The algorithm takes input blocks of 64 bytes, combines the data cryptographically, and generates a 256-bit (32 byte) output. The algorithm uses a simple round and repeats it 64 times. The diagram below shows one round, which takes eight 4-byte inputs (A through H), performs a few operations, and generates new values for A through H.

The dark blue boxes mix up the values in non-linear ways that are hard to analyze cryptographically. (If you could figure out a mathematical shortcut to generate successful hashes, you could take over Bitcoin mining.) The Ch "choose" box chooses bits from F or G, based on the value of input E. The Σ "sum" boxes rotate the bits of A (or E) to form three rotated versions, and then sums them together modulo 2. The Ma "majority" box looks at the bits in each position of A, B, and C, and selects 0 or 1, whichever value is in the majority. The red boxes perform 32-bit addition, generating new values for A and E. The input W_t is based on the input data, slightly processed. (This is where the input block gets fed into the algorithm.) The input K_t is a constant defined for each round.

As can be seen in this diagram, only A and E are changed in a round. The other values pass through unchanged, with the old A value becoming the new B value, the old B value becoming the new C value and so forth. Although each round of SHA-256 doesn't change the data much, after 64 rounds the input data will be completely scrambled, generating the unpredictable hash output.

The IBM 1401

I decided to implement this algorithm on the IBM 1401 mainframe. This computer was announced in 1959 and went on to become the best-selling computer of the mid-1960s, with more than 10,000 systems in use. The 1401 wasn't a very powerful computer even for 1960, but since it leased for the low price of $2500 a month, it made computing possible for mid-sized businesses that previously couldn't have afforded a computer.

The IBM 1401 didn't use silicon chips. In fact it didn't even use silicon. Its transistors were built out of a semiconductor called germanium, which was used before silicon took over. The transistors and other components were mounted on boards the size of playing cards called SMS cards. The computer used thousands of these cards, which were installed in racks called "gates." The IBM 1401 had a couple dozen of these gates, which folded out of the computer for maintenance. (Here you can see one of the gates is opened up showing the circuit boards and cabling.)

Internally, the computer was very different from modern computers. It didn't use 8-bit bytes, but 6-bit characters based on binary coded decimal (BCD). Since it was a business machine, the computer used decimal arithmetic instead of binary arithmetic and each character of storage held a digit, 0 through 9. The computer came with 4000 characters of storage in magnetic core memory; a dishwasher-sized memory expansion box provided 12,000 more characters of storage. The computer was designed to use punched cards as input, with a card reader that read the program and data. Output was printed on a fast line printer or could be punched on more cards.

The Computer History Museum in Mountain View has two working IBM 1401 mainframes, and I used one of them to run the SHA-256 hash code. For more information on the IBM 1401, see my article Fractals on the IBM 1401.