Skip to main contentSkip to navigationSkip to key eventsSkip to navigation

Election debate: reaction and analysis after Jeremy Corbyn and party leaders spar – as it happened

This article is more than 6 years old

Live feed

Key events

Rudd says the government has protected pensioners.

Corbyn and Robertson both challenge her to say they will protect the triple lock.

Rudd says they should read the manifesto.

Corbyn and Scots Nat bloke shouting at a woman: great look!

— Quentin Letts (@thequentinletts) May 31, 2017

"Please tell the pensioners how much they'd lose" @AngusRobertson demands. next defining moment in #BBCDebate

— Nick Robinson (@bbcnickrobinson) May 31, 2017
Share
Updated at 

Question 3 - Public services

Q: How can we trust you on public services? Where will the money come from?

Lucas says we could scrap Trident.

Husain turns to Rudd, and says there were no costings in the Conservative manifesto.

She says people should judge the Tories on their record.

This generates quite a lot of laughter from the audience.

Rudd turns to Brexit, and says Jeremy Corbyn would not deliver.

Corbyn says the Tory government has made choices: schools are overcrowded, hospitals are underfunded and students are saddled with debt.

Husain asks him if he is sure his plans add up. Only yesterday he could not remember the figures.

Corbyn says getting rid of tuition fees would cost £11bn. That would be money well spent.

Rudd is a bit like a disapproving teacher encountering a fracas in the sixth form common room

— Tim Shipman (@ShippersUnbound) May 31, 2017

Frankly, objectively, it is hard to picture Theresa May performing in this debate as strongly as Amber Rudd is right now. #BBCDebate

— Jim Pickard (@PickardJE) May 31, 2017

Robertson says this debate shames us all.

There is no one watching, from Cornwall to Caithness, who does not understand the contribution of immigrants. Demonising them shames us all.

He says Scotland’s problem has been emigration, not immigration.

Lucas says people like Nuttall and their “hate-filled rhetoric” are trying to persuade people that problems with the NHS are due to immigrants. They are not. They are due to under-investment, he says.

Corbyn says there has to be managed migration. We should no longer allow people to bring in people to undermine wages.

Robertson accuses Labour of aping Ukip. We should stay in the single market, he says.

Corbyn asks Robertson if he did not hear the result of the referendum.

Farron says Labour did not vote for the Lib Dem amendment that would have allowed EU citizens to stay in the EU.

Rudd says the government must act in the interests of all Britons, including those abroad.

Rudd says all this squabbling make her realise how chaotic a coalition would be.

Wood says she is in coalition with Ukip.

Lucas says Rudd was here a year ago saying we should stay in the EU. Will you get Boris Johnson to drive you home, she asks.

Defining moments of #BBCDebate on economy - Rudd attacks on Corbyn's "magical money tree" + Corbyn riposte "Have you been to a food bank?"

— Nick Robinson (@bbcnickrobinson) May 31, 2017

The Conservative strategy for the final week is now clear: Corbyn picks from the magic money tree & wants to put up immigration #bbcdebate

— Matthew Goodwin (@GoodwinMJ) May 31, 2017

Question 2 - Brexit

Q: When we leave the EU, how can we ensure that we protect living standards and have people with the right skills?

Nuttall calls for an Australian-style points system.

Farron says last week a middle-aged Asian man was abused on his way home from work. He had just finished 50 hours saving lives after the Manchester attack. He was a doctor.

That is what happens when you demonise immigrants.

He says May’s immigration target is “barmy”. It is a policy “written to appease Ukip”, he says.

Rudd says we must have an immigration policy we can control. She says although we will lower immigration, we will still attract the brightest and the best.

Husain asks Corbyn if he will reduce immigration.

Corbyn says all EU nationals must be allowed to stay.

Husain asks him to answer the question.

Corbyn says we would have a fair system.

Q: What is fair?

Fair is when people come here if they have a job, says Corbyn.

Nuttall criticises Labour for wanting to put up corporation tax.

Corbyn says he is talking complete nonsense. He says the government cut it. Labour is only returning it towards the level it was.

He asks Nuttall if he has been to food banks, if he has seen poverty.

His barb is aimed at Nuttall, but Rudd tries to answer.

Husain intervenes. She asks him how Labour’s plans would work.

Corbyn says the current system is not working. We cannot go on giving money away to the very rich. I say turn it round, he says.

Corbyn challenges Amber Rudd: "have you been to a food bank?" Cheers from the crowd...

— Faisal Islam (@faisalislam) May 31, 2017

Corbyn tells Nuttall he's talking rubbish, then pivots to attack Rudd. He's doing quite well. #BBCDebate

— Carl Dinnen (@carldinnen) May 31, 2017

This is from Sky’s Faisal Islam.

Totally different dynamic to this debate with Rudd there than the one without Cameron in 2015, where they all ganged up on Miliband...

— Faisal Islam (@faisalislam) May 31, 2017

Comments (…)

Sign in or create your Guardian account to join the discussion

Most viewed

Most viewed