How to Become Shamelessly Obsessed With Honey in 12 Easy Steps

When our writer fell in love with honey, she fell in love hard—and her cooking life became all the better for it. Now, she shares how you, too, can become a honey addict.

The addiction started eight years ago. I was visiting the Union Square Greenmarket for the first time, and there was a local beekeeper there. He had samples.

Free samples.

Lots of them.

Up until then I'd only tasted the overly sweet, one-note honeys that line most grocery store shelves. But these honeys were different. They were nuanced and complex. They smelled like flowers.

I bought a jar and brought it home. And ever since, I've been on a rampage, picking up a jar or two of local honey whenever I travel and precariously pining over the shelves at speciality food stores.

Now, my pantry is crammed. The shelves are sticky. They sag under the jars' weight.

I'm not alone in this addiction. "There's something about honey that can just hook you in," says Rebekah Peppler, Brooklyn-based food stylist and author of Honey. She's gone down the honey rabbit hole, too.

This is how to fall down that hole yourself.

Step 1: Learn How Honey Happens

A fascination with honey often starts with a fascination of how honey is made, a natural process that is as complex and perfect as anything happening at, say, Apple. To put it briefly: Honey is made from the nectar of flowers. Bees suck the nectar from flower blooms and store it in their stomachs. While there, the nectar mixes with protein and enzymes, which breaks the nectar down from sucrose into glucose and fructose. Once at the hive, the bees deposit the converted nectar into the cells of the hive and fan it with their wings until enough moisture evaporates that it has become the thick syrup we know as honey. The bees cap the cells with wax for storage (because honey isn't just food for us—bees feed on it as well), which indicates to a beekeeper that the honey can be collected.

Step 2: Align yourself with a varietal

Like wine, honey can be blends of several nectars, or they can be made solely with one type of nectar. A proper honey addict is familiar with the most common single-varieties, has respect for all of them, but has a few he or she loves more than the others. A few of the more than 300 varieties in the United States:

  • Acacia: From the yellow clusters of flowers of acacia trees, this is the sweetest, most delicate honey available. It's clear and almost agave-like.
  • Clover: Floral and mild. The most readily-available variety and good for all-purpose use.
  • Tupelo: From the flowers of Tupelo trees that grow in the swamps of north Florida, this is an extremely rare honey that has a clear, gold-toned color and a rich, buttery flavor.
  • Orange Blossom: Another great all-purpose honey, made from the white flowers of orange trees. Perfectly sweet, with fresh citrus undertones.
  • Buckwheat: One of the most robust varieties, from the flowers of the buckwheat plant. It's color is deep, dark brown and its flavor is reminiscent of molasses.
  • Chestnut: Another honey that isn't messing around. Strong and slightly bitter. This personal addict's favorite.
Photo by Chelsea Kyle, food styling by Sheela Prakash

Step 3: respect the blend

"When we place honey bees in an area where certain flowers are in bloom, we get that variety of honey," says Claire Tauzer, General Manager of Sola Bee Farms. Beekeepers will shuttle bees to certain locations to yield single-variety honeys—a clover field, say, to make clover honey.

But honey made from various types of flowers is also possible. "Honey bees will stick to a single source of nectar and pollen if it is clean and high quality. That said, in many areas and seasons there are many different types of plants blooming that are all healthy and nutritious for honey bees. This is why you get seasonal honey and varietals with more than one flower source, like wildflower honey."

It's perfectly acceptable to become addicted to a high-quality blend.

Step 4: Go through thick and thin

Honey addicts will quickly realize that every honey has its own consistency—some are translucent and flow freely, others creamy and spreadable, and a few thick and practically solid. This is due to the chemical makeup of the nectar that made the honey: the more glucose in the honey, the more likely it will be dense and opaque; the more fructose, the clearer and thinner the honey will be.

Honey addicts should embrace all honeys, regardless of its consistency, including crystallized honey. Tauzer notes: "Quality honey can be crystalized in the jar, which is actually a good thing. It shows that the honey you are buying has not been watered down or overheated and filtered."

Crystallized honey can be restored to its smooth, liquid consistency by placing the jar in warm water. But a true addict will spread it on toast as-is.

Step 5: Let go of the honey bear

At this point in your addiction you'll begin to suspect that the honey you've been pouring from those cute plastic bears all your life is amateur stuff. Not enough flavor. Eerily consistent.

It stings, but you're on the right path.

Honey bears "are not bad in and of themselves," says Tauzer. "But historically they have been used by very large importers of honey from China and other countries. It's hard to track the origin or actual flower source of these honeys, and if you don't know where it comes from, I wouldn't trust it."

Zeke Freeman, founder of Bee Raw, concurs. "It's honey, but it's honey that has been ultra-filtered to remove all traces of pollen and has likely been diluted with less expensive sugars to make it cheaper. Not having any pollen hides the original source of honey and makes it very difficult to tell if other less expensive sugars have been used to dilute the honey."

Time to let go of those honey bears, addict. Use up whatever bears you have lingering in your pantry, then kiss them goodbye.

Photo by Chelsea Kyle, food styling by Sheela Prakash

Step 6: Seek out raw experiences

Raw honey is honey that hasn't been heated past pasteurization. Because of this "it most likely has all of its beneficial pollen, amino acids and enzymes intact," says Freeman. Addicts like raw honey, because it has more nuance.

Steps 7-12: Use honey everywhere

How do addicts cook with honey? The better question is how do they not?

Morning honey—spread thick on toast or drizzled onto Greek yogurt or oatmeal—is the gateway meal for most addicts.

Roast meat and vegetables take particularly well to honey, caramelizing them and bringing out their rich flavors. "Orange Blossom honey has all these gorgeous citrus flavors, so combine it with lemon and brush it over roast chicken," Peppler says. Just note that honey can burn, so brush it on your roast during the last 10 to 15 minutes of cooking.

Honey addicts drink their honey as often as they eat it. "I keep a honey simple syrup in my fridge at all times," says Peppler. Experiment with different honeys: delicate Clover honey is a great match with gin, as it won't compete with its herbal notes, while spicy, molasses-like Buckwheat honey can stand up to darker spirits like rum and whiskey.

"Salad dressings are a great way to learn the different flavors of honey," says Peppler. Let the honey you reach for mimic the greens you are dressing: a strong, slightly bitter honey like Chestnut stands up well to kale or radicchio, while mild Acacia is a better match for delicate greens like butter lettuce.

Another well-loved combination is cheese and honey, a pairing that instantly upgrades a ho-hum cheese board. But which honeys to choose? Peppler recommends looking at the region that both are made—if the cheese and honey are produced in the same area, it's likely that they will go perfectly together. Lavender honey, which hails from Provence, France, is floral and not too sweet and pairs perfectly with fresh, tangy goat cheese, which is also produced all over the region.

The final frontier of cooking with honey: baking with honey. Since it's sweeter and more liquid than granulated sugar, you'll want to "err on the side of less honey than sugar—you’ll wipe out your tastebuds with one to one ratio," says Peppler. You'll also need to reduce the other liquids called for in the recipe. This requires a bit of trial and error. Not willing to play around? Other than using a recipe that intentionally calls for honey, the other no-fail option is to reach for recipes that call for other liquid sweeteners like maple syrup and molasses and swap honey in.