Skip to main contentSkip to navigationSkip to key eventsSkip to navigation

Government loses Sunday trading vote by majority of 31 – as it happened

This article is more than 9 years old

Rolling coverage of all the day’s political developments as they happen, including David Cameron and Jeremy Corbyn at PMQs and the Commons debate and vote on Sunday trading

 Updated 
Wed 9 Mar 2016 13.42 ESTFirst published on Wed 9 Mar 2016 04.00 EST
Key events
A sign outside a shop with Sunday trading hours. MPs are debating government plans to liberalise Sunday trading hours.
A sign outside a shop with Sunday trading hours. MPs are debating government plans to liberalise Sunday trading hours. Photograph: Steve Parsons/PA
A sign outside a shop with Sunday trading hours. MPs are debating government plans to liberalise Sunday trading hours. Photograph: Steve Parsons/PA

Live feed

Key events

Summary

  • Ministers suffered a serious defeat in the Commons as Conservative rebels lined up with Labour and the SNP to vote down plans to give councils the power to relax Sunday trading laws. A close vote had been expected, but in the event the government lost by a majority of 31 - a much larger margin than forecast. The defeat is particularly embarrassing for George Osborne, the chancellor, who made extending Sunday trading one of the key announcements in his post-election budget last year. Within the last week Osborne has also had to abandon plans for widespread pensions reform. It is David Cameron’s first major defeat of this parliament although, with a normal working government majority of just 16, more are bound to follow.
  • Twenty six Tory MPs voted against the government, Labour whips have claimed. A full voting list will be published later.
  • Ministers have strongly criticised the SNP for voting on a matter that does not directly affect Scotland. The government only lost because of the SNP vote, and Sajid Javid, the business secretary, described their behaviour as “childish and hypocritical”.

That’s all from me for tonight.

Thanks for the comments.

UPDATE: I’ve corrected the first paragraph so it says this was Cameron’s first major defeat of this parliament. Last year he suffered a less significant defeat on “purdah” rules and the EU referendum.

Share
Updated at 

The SNP’s Tommy Sheppard intervened on Sajid Javid to say that the SNP were just voting to protect the interests of their constituents.

Javid did not accept that. He replied:

[Sheppard] should be ashamed of his party’s performance today. He tries to behind a policy, but we know that the only thing the SNP was interested in today was headlines, and denying the people of England and Wales a change that through their MPs they clearly wanted to see.

Javid accuses SNP of 'childish and hypocritical' behaviour

In the Commons MPs are not embarked on the third reading of the enterprise bill.

Sajid Javid, the business secretary, has just accused the SNP of “childish and hypocritical” behaviour.

Sajid Javid tells the House that defeat on Sunday trading is "very disappointing".
Attacks SNP for "childish and hypocritical" behaviour.

— Jack Maidment (@jrmaidment) March 9, 2016

Javid tells Commons he "respects" those opposed to Sunday Trading in principle, but SNP's actions "childish and hypocritical"

— James Tapsfield (@JamesTapsfield) March 9, 2016

Minister says government would have won had it not been for SNP voting on non-Scottish law

Brandon Lewis, the communities minister who led for the government in the debate, says the government only lost because of the impact of SNP, who were voting on a law that would not affect Scotland.

Majority in English and Welsh MPs for Sunday Trading. SNP stop rest of country have freedom Scotland has.

— Brandon Lewis MP (@BrandonLewis) March 9, 2016

(At least, it would not affect Scotland directly. The SNP argued that relaxing Sunday trading in England might have a knock-on effect in Scotland, where Sunday opening hours are already more relaxed, but where workers are assured premium pay if they work on a Sunday.)

Jeremy Corbyn has welcomed the government defeat.

MPs were voting for a cross-party amendment opposing Sunday trading tabled by a Conservative MP, David Burrowes, but the government lost because Labour, the SNP, Tory rebels and some minor party MPs united behind it.

Government defeated as Labour stands up for working people #KeepSundaySpecial https://t.co/jhaEZfZvJR

— Jeremy Corbyn MP (@jeremycorbyn) March 9, 2016

This means that Sunday trading has been taken out of the bill.

It is a big, significant defeat, on an issue that was particularly championed by George Osborne, the chancellor.

Angela Eagle, the shadow business secretary, used a point of order to say Osborne should come to the Commons to make a statement.

(There is no indication he will.)

Government loses Sunday trading vote by majority of 31

The government has lost by 317 votes to 286 - a majority of 31.

This is from Labour’s Jon Trickett.

Nick Clegg just went into Tory Lobby on sunday trading!

— Jon Trickett (@jon_trickett) March 9, 2016

The Lib Dems have a free vote on this, apparently.

Share
Updated at 

Comments (…)

Sign in or create your Guardian account to join the discussion

Most viewed

Most viewed