Is Better Call Saul Better Than Breaking Bad?

It's the ultimate Mother Show vs. Spinoff showdown as we're asking you to weigh in on 20 heated competitions between sister-shows!

By Tierney Bricker Feb 12, 2015 4:25 PMTags
E! Placeholder Image

Has the lawyer surpassed the meth kingpin?

Better Call Saul, AMC's highly anticipated Breaking Bad prequel, delivered on its massive expectations in its series premiere last week, bringing in record cable ratings. Just how big was its debut? 6.9 million total viewers tuned in, with 4.4 million being in the all-important adults 18-49 demo, the latter of which is a new record. Breaking Bad's series premiere back in 2008? 1.4 million viewers tuned in.

BUT (There's always a but, right?) Breaking Bad didn't have the buzz or lead-in (Thanks, The Walking Dead!) Better Call Saul had, and Saul dropped by nearly 50 percent in its follow-up outing.

Of course, ratings and superiority do not go hand-in-hand, which is why we're saying to ask: do you think Better Call Saul is better than Breaking Bad?!

It's early, we know, but who doesn't love a good round of mother show vs. spinoff discussion?!

Plus, we also want you to weigh in on 19 other original series vs. spinoff debates to finally determine, once and for all, which is the better show! From old favorites like All in the Family and its two spinoffs The Jeffersons and Maude, to more recent entries, like Arrow and The Flash, sibling rivalry is always entertaining, no? And just for some laughs, we also included Friends  vs. Joey. (No disrespect to Matt LeBlanc!)

So vote in the polls below and then head on down to the comments to hash it out with your fellow fans. And make sure to come back on Monday when we reveal the results!

Poll

Mother Show vs. Spinoff: Which Is Better

Breaking Bad vs. Better Call Saul
Breaking Bad
80.4%
Better Call Saul
19.6%
The Vampire Diaries vs. The Originals
The Vampire Diaries
58%
The Originals
42%
Arrow vs. The Flash
Arrow
55.4%
The Flash
44.6%
Chicago Fire vs. Chicago P.D.
Chicago Fire
66.2%
Chicago P.D.
33.8%
Doctor Who vs. Torchwood
Doctor Who
82.8%
Torchwood
17.2%
Hercules vs. Xena
Hercules
48.5%
Xena
51.5%
The Daily Show vs. The Colbert Report
The Daily Show
60.1%
The Colbert Report
39.9%
Buffy the Vampire Slayer vs. Angel
Buffy the Vampire Slayer
81%
Angel
19%
Grey's Anatomy vs. Private Practice
Grey's Anatomy
87.7%
Private Practice
12.3%
Cheers vs. Frasier
Cheers
64%
Frasier
36%
Boy Meets World vs. Girl Meets World
Boy Meets World
93.8%
Girl Meets World
6.2%
All in the Family vs. The Jeffersons vs. Maude
All in the Family
63.4%
The Jeffersons
33.3%
Maude
3.3%
JAG vs. NCIS
JAG
27.8%
NCIS
72.2%
Pretty Little Liars vs. Ravenswood
Pretty Little Liars
84%
Ravenswood
16%
NCIS vs. NCIS: Los Angeles vs. NCIS: New Orleans
NCIS
73.4%
NCIS: Los Angeles
18.5%
NCIS: New Orleans
8%
CSI vs. CSI: Miami vs. CSI: NY
CSI
62.9%
CSI: Miami
28.1%
CSI: NY
9%
The Closer vs. Major Crimes
The Closer
77.4%
Major Crimes
22.6%
Law & Order vs. Law & Order: SVU vs. Law & Order: Criminal Intent
Law & Order
36.9%
Law & Order: SVU
54.6%
Law & Order: Criminal Intent
8.5%
Beverly Hills, 90210 vs. Melrose Place
Beverly Hills, 90210
76.9%
Melrose Place
23.1%
Friends vs. Joey
Friends
90.5%
Joey
9.5%